Exclusive: ‘Weakness is not in the commitments’: DSCC criticises inconsistent approach to seamount protection

The withdrawal of Armenia’s proposal to phase out high-seas bottom trawling has exposed inconsistencies in governments’ approach to marine conservation, according to Bronwen Golder, Seamounts campaign director at the Deep-Sea Conservation Coalition (DSCC).

eNews Image Draft (10)
Source: Francesco Ungaro from Pexels

Armenia withdrew a proposal to phase out bottom trawling on seamounts by December 2027 last Thursday. The withdrawal came after four days of negotiations, following opposition led by Japan, as well as the European Union (EU), Russia and the USA.

“The ‘red line’ rejection of the revised text proposals by Japan motivated Armenia to withdraw the proposed text so that it would not be compromised to the point of being meaningless,” said Bronwen Golder of the DSCC.

She also criticised the European Union’s negotiating position, arguing that its lack of consistency had undermined efforts to secure stronger protections.

“The European Union’s lack of a clear and consistent position was disappointing and ultimately weakened efforts to secure a stronger outcome for seamounts,” she said.

For the DSCC, the outcome proves particularly disappointing considering the support governments had previously given to protect marine ecosystems.

Golder pointed to the contrast in the EU’s support for the CMS Conversing Seamount Ecosystems resolution, compared to their acquiescence to Japan in last week’s talks.

“This suggests that the weakness is not in the commitments, but in the consistency of State positions on the protection of seamounts and other vulnerable marine ecosystems from destructive fishing practices,” Golder said.

Yet, the DSCC has not lost hope. Golder pointed to continued international support for the proposal from a broadly representative set of states, including Monaco, UK, Canada, Frace, Germany, Finland, Fiji, Vanuatu, and Sri Lanka, underpinned by scientific evidence of the damage caused by bottom trawling.

“The supporting States were also united in their recognition of the scientific evidence that unequivocally establishes the destructive impact of bottom trawling on seamount ecosystems and their associated and dependent species.”

“The fact that Japan and others felt the need to threaten a veto of the text proposed by Armenia was recognition of the level of support that they saw convening around the text.”

Existing international commitments to protect vulnerable marine ecosystems remain in place, Golder stressed, including UN, CBD and CMS measures, alongside binding protections established by regional fisheries management organisations (RFMOs).

Attention will now turn to the forthcoming Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ) agreement, with its next Conference of the Parties scheduled for January 2027.

Golder believes the agreement could place increasing pressure on states to fulfil their environmental responsibilities within RFMOs.

“That incentivisation of marine protection action – by the BBNJ on RFMO – is going to be significant and game changing.”